Cookie of the Month
An Experience With Every Cookie
Featured Products
Your Go-to Family Cookie Shop in New Haven
Cookie Thirty-Nine is your go-to family cookie shop, offering a vast array of cookies, each with its unique flavor and story. Our cookies are more than just treats; they're a unique experience crafted with love in New Haven, Connecticut, ready to treat every taste bud in the surrounding areas.
Why Our Cookies
Every purchase supports local causes.
Baked from scratch daily for unbeatable freshness.
Feels gourmet yet has Mama's house taste, and comfort.
Explore More
We are excited for you to taste our cookies and drinks, and explore our apparel collection, and take a stunning selfie with the mural on our wall that everyone wants to take pictures at. Cookie Thirty-Nine is your one-stop place for comfort, taste, and ambiance. Explore more about us.